1.         Benedict Schwope                    2.         Philip Wilhelm Otterbein       3.         Frederick Shaffer                      4.         Joseph Hoffman                        5.         Johann Schneider                      6.         Wilhelm Braun              7.         Johann Krock                           8.         Peter Herrman                          9.         Johann Russell              10.       Jacob Erb                               11.       George Miller                           12.       Johann Russell              13.       Samuel Enterline                       14.       Heinrich Schropp                      15.       Johann A. Sand                        16.       Carl Schneider                          17.       Nehemiah Altman                     18.       Jacob Doerksen                       19.       J.M. Kunkel                             20.       August Krauss                          21.       William Mittendorf                    22.       J.R. Blecker                             23.       August Schmidt                        24.       H.J. Fischer                              25.       J. G. Leuchauer                        26.       W. A. Webber                         27.       J.G. Leuchauer             28.       P.B. Gibble                              29.       Cawley H. Stine                       30.       John W. Luckens                      31.       Ezra H. Ranck                          32.       M. H. Welty                             33.       Paul D. Emenheiser                   34.       William C. Wachter                  35.       Paul E. Holdcraft (Emeritus) 36.       Harry E. Krone            37.       Rev. Krone / Rev. Holdcraft     38.       George B. Sprenkle /             Rev. Holdcraft              39.       G. B. Sprenkle 40.       Sprenkle, Holdcraft    41.       Frederick W. Mund, D.D.                    (Richard Reeves, Intern) 42.       Edward E. Prowant                  43.       Thomas R. Searfoss, Jr.             44.       Rev. Walter R. Harris               45.       Rev. Gordon Pratt Baker, Litt. D., 46.       Rev. Edwin Schell                     47.       Rev. Douglas Fox                     48.       Rev. Dr. Millard B. Knowles, D.D. 49.       Rev. Mernie Crane    *  Served as interim pastor from the death of Otterbein until the conference met in May 1814.   Bolded names were elected bishops of the EUB church.

1771 – 1774 1774 – 1813 1813 – 1814 (*) 1814 – 1817 1817 – 1825 1825 – 1828 1831 – 1835 1835 – 1839 1839 – 1841 1841 – 1848 1848 – 1851 1851 – 1854 1854 – 1857 1857 – 1860 1860 – 1867 1867 – 1870 1870 – 1873 1873 – 1877 1877 – 1880 1880 – 1885 1885 – 1889 1889 – 1893 1893 – 1910 1910 – 1915 April 1915 – May 1915 May 1915 – Sept. 1915 1915 – 1918 1918 – 1923 1923 – 1931 1931 – 1933 1933 – 1934 1934 – 1938 1938 – 1942 1942 – 1949 1949 – 1953 1953 – 1957 1957 – 1958 (Supplies) 1958 – 1960 (Co-Pastors)                    1960 – 1962 1962 – 1967 1967 – 1968 1967- 1968 June 1968 – January 15, 1969 January 15, 1969 – 1970 1970 – 1978 1978 – 1981 1981 – 1988 1988 – 1992 1992 – 2006                                      2006 - Present